Barn@Chelsea.jpg
by RayEthier

Comment:
Bright and lovely!

Shell Creek Road
by tinky2

Comment:
This picture is perfect.
Good lighting, placement rule of thirds, focus, colours, cropping, shadows, sharpness and everything.
Great landscape/tree picture.

French Hollyhock in Reverse
by tinky2

Comment:
Great use of inverting.
IMO a bit cropping from the bottom would give it more because the flower at the bottom is not in focus.
But again, great photo.

Complementary Glasses
by DigiFotoBuddy

Comment:
Comment from a member of your own commenting club :-)
Wow, you did a great job here.
It is hard to critique this shot. You probably would have cloned out the dust on the glass to the right if it wasn't Basic editing.
The cropping is perfect, actually much better than Jacko's.
This is what I see (and probably you to):
1. I would have liked to see a bit more of the outlines of the glass in the middle.
2. The glass in the middle should have been a bit closer so the top of it was a bit higher then the other two or to have it lower or to have it in the same hight. The way you have is more like you made a mistake.
3. I love the colours, the lighting is also great.

Message edited by author 2006-05-10 20:23:52.

just before dawn
by margiemu

Comment:
Comment from a member of your own commenting club :-)
I also love sunrises and sunsets. Specially the sunrise when there are still bright stars like Venus or Mercury.
There are some good things in this picture and there are some things that could easily been done better without much trouble.
1. Your picture is only 540x329 in size. You should use the maximum on at least one side of it. In this case it would have been 640x390.
2. The picture is only 23680 Bytes. Believe me I know the trouble saving pictures in Windows (don't have PS now) and loosing information. Maybe your picture was sharper before saving. It is best to use all the 150KB when you can.
3. Using rule of thirds, The moon and the star, wich are the main topic in the picture should be a little bit more to the left. The hight of the moon and star are fine.
4. Lovely colours but I would like to either see a bit more of the mountains (brighter) or make them as dark as the trees.
5. Focus, It is hard to see if the focus is bad or if it is because of the jpeg compression. I know it can be hard to focus near things, like a tree, trying to focus the moon at the same time. Doing this you have to have the trees in a distance, as much as you can. If you want to have full focus on the moon and see its landscapes you have to have about 200 in shutter speed but then everything else turns black in the night.

Message edited by author 2006-05-10 20:23:17.

Papillon Profile
by Paige

Comment:
Nice profile view.
You could maybe have used a bit of NeatImage to get rid of the grain.
But this is overall a lovely shot.

Hike, hike, hike.
by dris

Comment:
Hike as you like
But the stairs are for loosers
:-)
Nice shot, would be a bit better though if there was more light on the leftmost person. Also a step backward would have placed the first and last persons better.

A New Breed
by trumpetwalrus

Comment:
I am colourblind (red/green) but still I can see that this is red and green. Arent they complimentary colours?

Originally posted by sammigurl: None of those are complimentary colors.

Iris
by charliebaker

Comment:
It can not be his fault that everybody else is submitting the same thing.

Originally posted by I Enjoy Ham: too common in this challenge

Lolita
by mannjudit

Comment:
Is she a Cliché?