If we pull this off!
by Caltrop

Comment:
Why oh why did you not enter this in the Challenge???

Greener on the Far Side
by Pegasus

Comment:
Good job. If you're using Photoshop or Photoshop Elements, look into the liquify filter. You could've bulged the cow's eyes without adding them in yourself.

Unlucky
by Sonifo

Comment:
Good job. I find I con't really comment in a negative way in these. All I can say is that you've recreated a classic.

Cowsmetic Surgery
by skewsme

Comment:
Hummm...I think those aren't udders. It is a classic Larson toon though. Good job.

Gary Larson Tribute
by lynnmarie

Comment:
Good job on recreating a classic.

...
by timfythetoo

Comment:
Good God, I love this kind of humor! This one's a classic too!

What We Say to Cats...and What They Hear
by freakin_hilarious

Comment:
A classic... I bet you wish you had a dog for this shot!

No Handbag
by timfythetoo

Comment:
Yeah! Even better with your daughter!!!

Saturday Afternoon
by aimeethetoo

Comment:
*Critique Club*
Aimee! Your pic was given to me to critique for the Critique Club.
As I always state, I'm in no way a pro at this. I just like pictures. I must say I'm honored to be able to critique one of your pics. I'm developping a sequence to my critiquing, so here goes...
What your pic made me feel: I feel a sense of awe. Wow...how small we are. I can hear the stream, feel the wind. The echo of the rock hitting the bottom of the cave...That guy up there threw it.
What I like about your submission: I like the composition. I think it fits the challenge real well. Nothing in there is overpowering. It's well balanced. I like what you achieved with the lighting. Nice soft natural light with Sun rays peeking through. The Sun leaves brightness and shadows though! I kinda like the cave ceilling in the top left. I find it frames your cave.
What I like a bit less: The patch of sunlight on the ground and in the stream. It gets that part overexposed...But... I know there's not much you can do about that! Same thing for the sky, but to a lesser degree.
I'm trying to figure this out myself. I almost always end up with a blown out or cyan sky! I'm really wondering how this would've come out in HDR. Would be interesting.
I think the comments you got were spot on. To quote xXxscarletxXx: "Absolutely beautiful" Good job!!!

John

powder (blue) room
by chele

Comment:
I dunno, really. It's a blue ceilling...Never seen that before. It's an out of focus light. It's a wall in need of repairs. It's a blown out pair of windows (overexposed). I really can't give this a high score.
Reasons: Out of focus light, bad composition with no subject, overexposed windows.
I don't want to be mean, but I know you can do better.