Moving Out...
by sfarrell23

Comment:
I gave this a five. I like the overall perspective. I think waiting until the train was looming closer in the frame (or moving in closer if it's not a moving train) would have created a more imposing subject. The overall seen is much too contrasty. I don't think you need quite as much sky. If you can go back and do this again (lowering the contrast on your camera if you can) you have the makings of an excellent shot.

Crystal Cave
by Links 2 3 4

Comment:
I gave this a five for effort. It looks like you went out of your way to find something new to shoot. I don't love the shot but technically there's not a lot to complain about. Perhaps tighter framing on the central formation? The flash created quite a few overly hot highlights. The focus seems sharper onthat little turd shaped thing underneath the central formation.

For your eyes only
by RUEDISCHMUTZ

Comment:
I gave this a five because it technically looks pretty good and it's fairly original. Otherwise, it doesn't do much for me.

A Dance With a Ghost
by artvet

Comment:
I gave this a five. I wanted to score higher because I generally like this type of image. Unfortunately, it was just too blurred and double exposed looking. There should have been one 'solid' subject to focus on.

Spring Flowers
by Mobius

Comment:
I gave this a five. It would have been a six but I felt that the few spots of green leaves poking through the mass of color detracted from the effect. I also really dislike the tacky thin red line in the border.

Meet Me On The Roof
by mocabela

Comment:
I gave this a five because overall it is pretty good technically. I didn't like the clashing of colors in the rose and the wine. I know the title is meet me on the roof but I don't like the asphault shingles as background.

Cheers!
by peete

Comment:
It took me two viewings over two days to realize what this was. I gave it a five. I think it has a lot of technical merit. I just didn't love it that much.

My First Cat Photograph
by Tallbloke

Comment:
I gave this a five. I like the cat's smug expression withhis slight wink. I like the framing. There could be a bit more detail in the cat's face. I know this is difficult with a black cat. One of my cats is all black. I'm kind of sceptical that you've never photographed a cat before but I guess if you aren't a cat lover it's possible. ^..^

My first insect
by andywightman

Comment:
I thought you captured the details on the fly beautifully, right down to the irridescent colors but for some reason this shot just doesn't wow me. For that reason I gave it a five. I don't usually like to be vague but I think in this case it is just a matter of taste.

Morning Harbor
by SusanFern

Comment:
I gave this a five. It is a nice composition and I like the reflections. It's a bit too contrasty (the lights are too light and the darks too dark). Much of the detail is washed out.