Lots of threads, one strong rope
by AndyGT

Comment by hotpasta:
wonderful clarity...wish you saved your shot at 640px though...521px is too small to judge properly

Pea Pod Pool
by AndyGT

Comment by Elvis_L:
the reflections on the water are nto working for me. colors seems washed out.

Pea Pod Pool
by AndyGT

Comment by sherpet:
I like this effect.....

Pea Pod Pool
by AndyGT

Comment by Fayea:
OOooo loads of color! it makes me giddy. anyway very nice job.

Pea Pod Pool
by AndyGT

Comment by Alain:
It looks like a good picture but it's hard to say because it is too small. You would get more points by posting a bigger picture.

Pea Pod Pool
by AndyGT

Comment by rinac:
Darn it, wish it was bigger.

Pea Pod Pool
by AndyGT

Comment by hotpasta:
too small to really judge properly...I do like the colour in the reflection but it's hard to tell if this is any good

Jagged Edges
by AndyGT

Comment by Philos:
Critique Club Comment.

Hi,

I picked your photo for a critique so lets start.
Please keep in mind that this is still a personal opinion, and in no way I know better then anybody else, but I will try to help you to improve your score.

First of al your subject.
It meets the challenge, it is glass, but as has been said, it could also be ice.
You need to try to create impact into your subject if you want to get higher votes.
Keep in mind that voters need to vote on a lot of photoĂ¢€™s so most of them will score you in just 2 seconds.
The lighting could be improved a bit too, as could the background.
Bright colours score well here at DPC, Blue, Red, Yellow etc.
I am sure that if you had used a piece of bright blue or yellow paper as the background that your score would go up almost a point.
Last thing I want to talk about is the lighting, because the top corner of the picture is very dark and there is some noise and lines in that dark.

Again, this is all just personal opinion, but I hope it helps you somewhat.

If you have any comments or questions or want to yell at me, you can PM me.

Looking forward to your next entry

Peter

Deer at dusk
by AndyGT

Comment by jjstager2:
I would have liked a tighter shot.

Deer at dusk
by AndyGT

Comment by atupdate:
Needs more contrast to give the image more depth. 5