Canyon river
by Zhemaitis

Comment:
Looks like a polarizer was used. On my monitor this looks dark but looks like a good composition. Just needs more post processing to bring out the wonder hidden in the scene. :(

Hmmmm... given the wide halo above the left side hills it strikes me that you may have used HDRI with this image. If so, you will want to go back and redo that because it appears underexposed and you will want to correct that. If not corrected in HDRI then fix it with standard editing adjustments.

When night is falling...
by hajeka

Comment:
Bummer... so many wonder elements in the image and your timing is perfect. The sky, color and overall technical quality of this picture is poor. Consider a BW treatment and other post processing things you might do to highlight the bird, windmill(s) and sunrise. If you want to stay with color you will have to do some serious color adjustments to add visual interest to this image. Work on sky color more than anything else. It totally lacks viewer interest as it is.

Little Red Sailboat
by deepfrog17

Comment:
Wonderful BW treatment with dramatic clouds and technically very well done. Not fond of the red sail and feel it is a distraction. Composition and framing are not as strong as it might be but it is a 'good' image. I'm working on a multi-image landscape panorama right now and your image reminds me of it because of your wide but narrow presentation which is common of panoramas. Don't know if yours is a multi-image panorama but I don't want mine to 'look' like a panorama. If interested I will share my work with you if I can ever get it 'right' and you are interested. LOL!!!

A River Flood As Seen From A Passing Train Window
by EssAreDubya

Comment:
Interesting and very worthy compositional subject but your treatment of it in post processing does not do the scene justice.

The Wharf
by alecnorman

Comment:
Good BW with very nice light highlghting on the posts but looks like the horizon is NOT level (looks to be rotated clockwise to the actual horizon and it APPEARS to have to much noise reduction applied in the foreground. (I could be wrong about noise reduction but that does not matter because in photography appearences are EVERYTHING)

Harmony
by nickymwhite

Comment:
Small size and a large and somewhat distracting black border seriously hurts the appeal of this otherwise wonderful scene.

Spring Forest
by Tom_Robbrecht

Comment:
The choice to compose the large number of tree trunks, as opposed to including the whole trees, contrasted against the wildflowers carpeted on the forest floor is clearly the strength of this composition. The path just adds more viewer interest to the image.

Desert Rocks
by BAMartin

Comment:
Looks like this may have been taken in Phoenix, Arizona USA in or near the Desert Botanical Gardens. May not be true but I am pretty sure this is the Sonoran Desert, a place near and dear to my heart. :) Like the cacti and rocks, but the main 'mountain' (Papago Peaks?) is insufficient to carry the whole composition. An additional element in the foreground would add considerable viewer interest to the composition.

Maunga-a-Reipae - "Watchful Mountain"
by julesski

Comment:
Don't like the near centered tree orientation, especially when there is so little of viewer interest on the far left that could be cropped out for a better tree off set with more viewer interest. The tree and its shadow is the main subject and you want to do EVERYTHING possible to highlight it.

Defiance
by MeGoobie

Comment:
Nice image with decent tones, good BW. Looks like the Oregon, USA coast to me. Chosing to use 720 pixels for the vertical height is not a good one for most images because of screen limitations and will result in lower scores from some viewers.