Decay
by Froober

Comment:
Was the glare across the top on purpose? I don't get any extra meaning from it. I kinda like the glare through the tree leaves. 6 Swash

"Travel to a different time zone"
by clicker

Comment:
Very nice. The closest thing to a "problem" that I see with this photo is the tank, it seems a tad too bright. On the other foot, compensating for that might have made some of the other parts of the train too dark, so I feel you balanced this about as good as possible. 9 Swash

Sole Survivor
by LindaLee

Comment:
Very cool picture. I am assuming you wanted the shoe and foreground as the only focal points, but I want more. The shoe seems on the dark side. I wish I could read the document title. 8 Swash

Vintage FM
by mcmurma

Comment:
Very cool! I esp. like the faded hand. This is the kind of added action that several others in this challenge needed, well done! In fact, this is sooo good, I have to award you two more points! 10 Swash

Stone Age Cuisinart
by myqyl

Comment:
Simple, yet effective. I think this could have been a 10, with more of a story behind this shot. Some grain in the bottom, maybe some ground up would have told this story more completely. The background could be more effective for showing off the subject if it contrasted more. 9 Swash

The Tipton Place
by indigo997

Comment:
This is a beautiful setting! (Seems a little overly green, is that just me?) Nice job! (needed a break from commenting the 6's) I can't think of any suggestions to improve this shot, so I'm raising your score from a 9 (first impression was very good!) to a 10 (lasting impression equally good or better!) Swash

78 rpm
by floyd

Comment:
Cool shot, very nice focal range! The glare is perfect, no matter what anybody else says. I try to not compare other shots, but here's an exception. The other record shot is on the turntable, much better "interest" to me. On the other hand, this shot is SOOO much clearer....(I ended up giving you both the same score). I don't know which is better, maybe on the turntable, but not turning? 8 Swash

My Retirement In Shreds
by cameo

Comment:
Glad you used ones! Can you tape them back together (or did you make your own money)? Nice shot. Suggestion: how about un-bottling the money, spreading it around as your background, instead? I can't think of any photographic advise or suggestions. Good focus, nice layout (less than REALLY exciting). 8 Swash

Steppin' to Success
by karmat

Comment:
Really great concept. Nicely executed. A tad more light might have been nice, but maybe you did this to create a darker mood. (call it a push) I keep looking back at the pant leg. It's so minor, but seems more sleezy than uptown, you know what I mean? (Golf shoes would have been "classic!) 9 Swash

dot com
by stephan

Comment:
Neat trick! The colors in the shadow are great, subtle, but great! Your connection to the challenge is less loose than most, so good job there, too. Was the darkness on both sides on purpose? I am also fascinated by the "light" edges around the lettering (how?). 8 Swash