Make A Wish
by Sammie

Comment:
I like you caught the 'plunk' of the coin, but, for some reason this image isn't that interesting to me. its a great idea. But maybe the darkness of the rocks makes it bland. Mostly when I hear or have seen this superstition, it is in a well or a fountain, this apears to be a river? can't really tell.

Lookin' for a wee bit o' luck...
by DemonLlama

Comment:
This made me laugh at first look. could be a little bit of a double meaning here L()L. I think maybe a more washed out look on the model, so the 'clovers' would pop out more. Having even lighting across this image would also have helped it.

"There's Gold Up in Dem Hills"
by Cutter

Comment:
Personaly, I don't care for these type of shots. with the water looking like foam or smoke or cloud or whathave you. It is not an image I really care for, looking at the other elements as well. For soem reason it really doesn't hold my attention. and the 'gold' looks added on in pp. Doesn't sell the image for me.

Deadly Combination
by steffyld

Comment:
Fun idea. Could have been pulled off in a number of ways. Here I think you need more contrastiness and up the saturation a bit. Maybe a little lower of a n angle also would work better.

It's Raining Bad Luck
by carpents

Comment:
Im thinking black raindrops or confettie or something. it needs a Visual effect to show 'It's' Raining. other wise this is more along the lines of 'Is it' Raining.

Also, doesn't give me the feel that he is indoors. The lighting suggests outdoors. Even though the doorway looks inside.

Big Ben - outsmarting fishermen for 30 years...
by notesinstones

Comment:
Big Ben doesn't look all that big. Maybe a tighter crop or a closer view of the fish to make him look unusually large. Little contrasty also to help the image pop.

Lava
by smilebig4me1x

Comment:
The flashlight seems to have created an overpowering highlight on things. A little distracting.

Everything else seems to work very well. Although maybe a little tighter crop.. not much.. just a little.

Sea of Mist
by smilebig4me1x

Comment:
This is really fun, it draws me in and wants me to look deeper in. Keep the positioning, but maybe a little tighter crop would make this even more dramatic, The shapes on the shell with light and colour are intresting. Maybe throw something more colourful in front for it to reflect off of and create an illustion of colour within the shell.

The Mill
by Artan

Comment:
Very nice image. The colour is a smidge unrealistic to me, but overall.. very nice job.

Since 1831 AD
by armin

Comment:
Nice antiqueing. truely gives an old photo feel. I think this was executed very well. Would have to say the best one yet.