A Pale View Of The Hills
by e301

Comment:
This is a particularly great picture... not sure how it will do in this challenge...but very interesting.

The Delivery
by GolferDDS

Comment:
I think I'd be much more impressed if you somehow managed to do this with just the camera, but its a great subject for a shot like this - almost reminds me of an old Coke advertisement. All in all - good composition, great idea and solid editing.

Help, Help! I'm Being Eaten
by ajschmidt

Comment:
This is a great subject, nice focus and colours, but overall the composition is a little boring.

viewfinder
by Amason

Comment:
Well done, I really would love to get a look at the full sized version of this, if beautiful.

My Little Mountain
by soup

Comment:
Well I hope the entry you chose does well, because this is really great.

Battle Lines
by Cam

Comment:
Hehe, well done, a first place and a 5th place from essentially the same shot.... thats what I call efficiency!. The funny thing is that in both circumstances you met the challenge perfectly.

As for the execution... I didn't really like the original.. but this one is a really great shot. Good job of learning from your past efforts and improving.

Im also curious as to how big these replicas are? Im assuming they arent lifesize like the real thing (by real thing I mean the ones in China) ??

Message edited by author 2004-11-01 18:36:55.

One Of Many. Why?
by Mark of SRQ

Comment:
This picture makes me uncomfortable, which is exactly what it should. Might be better in black and white. 7.

Famished
by connie

Comment:
I remember looking at this shot during the challenge and thinking something along the lines of 'this should win, but it won't'. Unfortunately it seems I was right.

Terrific tones and composition, well done.

FORENSICS
by medinfo2000

Comment:
Well the picture is exceptionally ordinary, but I do like the morbid humour

(Cringe)

reading, 'riting and 'rithmetic
by umbris

Comment:
Not exactly exciting, but the fact that the books are so old at least held my interest enough to click on the thumbnail. I really like the Lighting here though, so definately above average