Unobtainium
by Mick

Comment:
Nice abstract way of meeting the challenge, I like it! :)

Oxidation of Iron: Fe » Fe²+ + 2e¯
by DrAchoo

Comment:
Seems to be some kind of weird motion blur over the image, or some kind of blur anyway. Nothing seems in focus.

New idea!
by Djabordjabor

Comment:
Is this the same shoot as the other one? Well I'll repeat my comment then. The light bulb/electricity is physics rather than chemistry, but I do like how the backlighting catches the hair. I think this photo's composition is better than the other one too.

I have an idea!
by tumitumi

Comment:
Light bulbs/Electricity are really Physics rather than chemistry. Still, the backlighting catching the hair is nice here.

Oxidation
by snowleopard10101

Comment:
I think the border spoils the photo here. The colour choice on it was bad imo and its a major distraction. The apple also seems too close to the edge on the left and bottom.

Golden Stem
by sherpet

Comment:
I really like the curves and colours here, which are really nicely complimented by the black lines. These darker lines really give the shot a nice substance and make it look like a painting :)

Message edited by author 2006-09-11 08:25:27.

Parked
by Melethia

Comment:
Composition: 6 - The shapes and crop you've chosed show interesting patterns, but perhaps more of an angle would add more drama?
Technical: 3 - The high contrast works to some extent, especially well at the bottom of the frame, but the top it causes all the whites to blend and just look a bit "mish-mashed".
Creativity: 6 - A risky shot for DPC but the patterns and repetition were well spotted :)
Appeal: 4 - The high contrast black and white is normally something that appeals to me, but this goes a little too far in my opinion.

Overall Calculated Average Score: 5

Row Boat
by robs

Comment:
Composition: 4 - Interesting, but doesnt really show the subject very well.
Technical: 5 - Nice exposure and good contrast. Nice colours in the sky too. Could have used a larger image size in this challenge to show the detail better, which a sharpen would also help.
Creativity: 5 - A different angle would add more uniqueness to the shot.
Appeal: 4 - Doesn't hold my interest for long because there is not enough of the row boat shown.

Overall Calculated Average Score: 4

Spirit of a tree
by timmi

Comment:
Composition: 7 - In this case the centeredness works I think.
Technical: 6 - Nice appealing colour gradient, and teh silhouette looks good. I'm not sure if the texture is natural or post processed in, but either way I find it a little distracting. The whole thing could be a little sharper too.
Creativity: 7 - Nice idea and executed well :)
Appeal: 6

Overall Calculated Average Score: 6

Here comes the sun.
by zardoz

Comment:
Composition: 6 - The crop at the top seems a little tight, but the leading lines of the shore work well to guide the eye. Shame there's nothing at the end of them.
Technical: 6 - Seems oversharpened to me, and a bit on the bright side, but not too bad.
Creativity: 5 - I think with something in the shot to give it a point of interest it would look more unique.
Appeal: 5

Overall Calculated Average Score: 5