Darkened Salmon on Israelien Couscou
by RedOak

Comment:
Slightly oversaturated? But very good! Would have preferred a plain table cloth- this is slightly distracting. 6

Scrambled egg
by hmair

Comment:
OK. Normally I am not a strict interpreter of the challenge descriptions but in this case I have to take off points for your entry which to me is not a recipe but an excellent stop motion. I do this because your entry could easily have been saved for a more appropriate competition. It is not time sensitive as you could have produced it at any time. It is a great photo nonetheless but I just don't think that special effects (without a recipe) should win this one. 5

Omlette with Lox Feta and Spinach
by _eug

Comment:
Very nicely done. I like everything in focus and the dark bacground works well. The silverware is a distraction (I probably would like to see them on the plate or ommitted) 7

Oreo cookie cheese cake
by lcfourstar

Comment:
Over saturated (or sharpened) Maybe a little out of focus? 6

Last nights dinner .... untainted and ready to eat!
by kari1

Comment:
Bad title. For me the composition is a little wierd. What would have happened if the glass were moved between the two dishes? I think you would have gotten a tighter crop and a more prominent presentation. Also I do not like the lighting on the wine. 6

Tollhouse Temptation
by Beach_mel

Comment:
Nicely done! Question: Would it have been even better if the crumbs were in focus too? 7

Add Water
by karmat

Comment:
The background does not add to the photo. The tea bag's tone looks a little dull. I would rather have seen a brightly colored cup or some other accent. I like the concept though. 6

Gung Gaeng Panang Kao Suey
by michael_p

Comment:
It seems that the coloring could have been punched up a bit; seems a tad dull.6

Black Bean and Corn Salsa
by bowhenn

Comment:
I think that the entire dish should be in focus. 6

Creamy Beef Lasagna
by Brenb

Comment:
Would prefer a constant focus over the whole dish. 6