Out And About Again
by lshles

Comment:
Great take on the challenge. Most people thought of their kids ... very few would recognize that the elderly seek a return of their independence. I like that the hand shows the age of your subject, while the top of the cane portrays the ability to get out on their own. I hope more people recognize the symbolism in this photo. Great work! :)

Solo
by nico_blue

Comment:
This is my favorite ... I can almost hear the music. The lighting, the motion, the composition, all of it is great. My top pick ... I hope it ribbons! :)

The Ducky Lover
by Joey Lawrence

Comment:
Omigod! That is totally hysterical! I love it! :)

I can hardly even tell the duck is pasted in the photo. You are great Joey! :)

Ancient Celtic Roots
by amber

Comment:
Amber - I have to agree with the "post challenge" posts. In no way does this photo deserve less than a 4. In no way does it derserve less than a 5! That's just crazy! I took one look at it, and totally understood. For someone to actually write "roots and family don't tie", you'd think they'd get it as they were typing it!

Keep up the good work. I love to just stare at this photo, and think about the symbolism of it. I know I'm no "expert", but I know what I like what I like. :)

Like Father, Like Son
by deapee

Comment:
What an awesome capture! I really love it! Not only the tone and feel of the two "boys", but the gradient sky is awesome, along with the boats and water in the background. Great capture! :)

Street Declaration
by neophyte

Comment:
Great idea ... the reflection of the street sign is a little distracting, tho.

Imagining the Summit
by neophyte

Comment:
By looking at your portfolio, I definitely see that you know how to take a photo. I don't agree with some of these comments, that you just "stuck" a photo in here and gave it a name. That's not fair to you. I see where you were coming from. Don't let your low score get you down. Mine didn't do too hot either. :)

I love the fact that you caught him reaching for his next grasp. I agree with stdavidson, that setting a black point and then adjusting levels would have made a difference. Unfortunately, I think it was the photos content that got you the low score.

Good luck!

Message edited by author 2005-06-30 07:28:15.

Darkness Awakens
by jtstreet

Comment:
I really liked this, inspite (or because) of the filter. Could be because I'm a Star Wars fan. :) Sorry it didn't do better, but for the record, I gave you a six.

Consuming
by Joey Lawrence

Comment:
Awesome shot! I sense the pain and anguish. The red adds to the feeling, and blends well into the darkness. Great photo, and great job!

Noir
by nico_blue

Comment:
This was my highest rated photo. Congrats on the top 20. If you care, what I love about it:

- The eyes in shadow, conveying sorrow
- The hands gripped in front of the face, as if afraid
- The deep shadows and highlights contrasting against each other - can't have the darkness without the light!

It just me stare at it, which is a good thing in MY book! :)
Tara