Flying Tiger
by pncowley

Comment:
Oh wow. This stirs emotions with me as my grandpa flew for the Flying Tigers in China. Good shot, but it seems to be a bit over compressed.

Stonehenge
by Konador

Comment:
Wow.. I really really like this shot. The red tone gives an otherworldly feel to it. The connection to Pi is rather tenuous. Still 7.

Alien Beings Help in War Against Iraq
by jenarom

Comment:
The picture isn't all that great. It's the extra editing you've done that really sets this apart and makes it funny. Good!

Firehouse Humour - Green Tar and Feathers
by mariomel

Comment:
Okay.. while I'm not a big fan of the Joke here, I'm really a sucker for a good pan. This constitutes a good pan. The green makes it a bit surreal too. Good job.

Time flies
by xertion

Comment:
You know... I take my minor nitpick back. I just realized that the reflection makes the clock look like it has wings.. I like it more now!

Counting Down Time with a Paper Chain
by sabal5

Comment:
Greets from the Critique Club:

Initial impression:
Nice colors, distracting shadows, jumbled composition.

Challenge:
I admit that I didn't see the connection to time when I voted on this picture, but after reading the comments I now see the connection. Very creative and neat idea. I remember those days fondly.. Unfortunately I've found it doesn't pay to be too creative around here.

Composition/Creativity:
I'm not sure what to say here. The composition feels jumbled and messy, but I have a feeling that's caused by the shadows.

Technical/Post-Processing:
This is where this photo lets me down. The flash is far too harsh. Try more light without the flash nexttime!

Overall:
Not a strong/apparent enough reference to time. Flash. Good idea and great colors though!

-Matt

Frozen Time
by bosniak

Comment:
Greets from the Critique Club:

Initial impression:
Cold, nice idea, missing something

Composition/Creativity:
This is a good idea and I like that in a photo. The composition is good, though I think I'd like to see more space around the sides of the subject. The reflection adds interest but also clutters the photo a little.

Technical/Postprocessing:
Exposure and lighting are very good, the a bit more contrast could have been added in post processing to add that extra little bit of punch.

Overall:
Great idea, executed well. Should have scored higher in my opinion! Keep up the good work!

-Matt

Triptych: Old Faded Emotions
by kosmikkreeper

Comment:
Greets from the critique club:

This is an ingeneous idea and I really like the way you've done it. It took me a little while to figure out how exactly you did it, but I think I know now. (Or at least I know how I'd do it!)

Of course, this pic meets the challenge very well. Techinically it's outstanding, however I have two main gripes. One, the emotions do seem very forced. Two, on the picture on the right I don't like the intensity of the light. Other than that this is perfect.


Good job!

-Matt

Light
by PixelatedVisions

Comment:
Interesting perspective! I even like the coloring..

Reflections of interest
by xertion

Comment:
Good lord this is just wonderful! The clouds, the reflections, the illusions. I can't think of anything I'd change about it. Great Job!