Miracle in basic editing
by graphicfunk

Comment:
I'm coming from here and I must say this is an absolutely awesome idea! Great job!

Love Page
by danielcheong1974

Comment:
I think I've seen something like this before here on DPC. What does the DPC etiquette say when it comes to copying others' ideas (except in "Deja vu" challenges)? (Or was it originally yours?) I honestly don't know, it might be encouraged or frowned upon.

I'll start a forum thread to ask about this, just out of curiosity. I'd like to emphasize that although your image triggered the question, the thread is not meant to be about your picture. (I'm saying this because my intentions have been misinterpreted before in a similar situation.)

Dusk on the Water
by rjkstesch

Comment:
Seems a bit skew to me. Rotating the picture slightly clockwise would fix this. Otherwise very nice.

backroads
by dstrohl

Comment:
Wow, wow, wow! Looks like a scene out of a movie (and not just because of the black borders)! I like the shallow DOF. I like the expression (this guy is damn serious!). I like the lighting. I like the background that tells us where this might be taking place. What did you do to the colors to make them seem movie-like?

Great job. I hope it does well. 10.

Brick factory
by SoulMan1978

Comment:
I think I've seen this before, but with a pencil in it. ;-) Barry?

Good idea to take the picture in the evening.

Foggy Night
by bruski

Comment:
Very cool lighting. The two little lights in the background and their cable, however, are an unnecessary distraction. I think the picture would be better without them. Still one of my favorites in the challenge.

The Long Way Home
by dsidwell

Comment:
Almost a ribbon! Love this shot, my favorite in the challenge.

fast track to oblivion
by roz

Comment:
Wow! I like the composition, the expression and the altered reflection as a "preview" of things to come. It perfectly fits the challenge and deserves a ribbon. I hope you don't get too many 1, 2 and 3 votes of people who have this knee-jerk reaction to vote low on anything unpleasant.

Oh No !!
by senor_kasper

Comment:
Fun idea and good execution, very cute. I hope no animals were harmed for this one. ;-)

Cross my Heart and Hope to Die
by Ubersteiny

Comment:
I like the composition, the lighting, the shallow DOF, but the title (if I understand it correctly) is disturbing. I guess you'll get some very low votes and furious comments (people saying "You promote violence against women!" and stuff like that). However, I appreciate the effort and the well thought out setup. The picture tells a story and conveys emotions. And it fits the challenge perfectly. 9.