Welcome Home
by kirbic

Comment:
One of the more acceptable sepia treatments I have seen in this challenge and I am bumping you up two points for that and the composition since reveiwing my scoring.

"The Wars Of the Old Discard There Ruins For The New To Find "
by Jecto

Comment:
The deep sepia obsures the details that are available in this image. By lightening the tone, the detail will emerge and the veiwer doesn't need to work to capture the feel, mood, emotion that should come easily. The contrast between the grey tones in the sky and the sepia in the forground difficult to visually accept (By the way, IMO)

OLD SHED
by pookey83

Comment:
The deep sepia obsures the details that are available in this image. By lightening the tone, the detail will emerge and the veiwer doesn't need to work to capture the feel, mood, emotion that should come easily. (By the way, IMO)

The king no longer abides
by fstopopen

Comment:
I could copy and past this to several other images in this challenge: The deep sepia obsures the details that are available in this image. By lightening the tone, the detail will emerge and the veiwer doesn't need to work to capture the feel, mood, emotion that should come easily. (By the way, IMO)

Old Farmers House
by setecha

Comment:
I could copy and past this to several other images in this challenge: The deep sepia obsures the details that are available in this image. By lightening the tone, the detail will emerge and the veiwer doesn't need to work to capture the feel, mood, emotion that should come easily. (By the way, IMO)

Forgotten
by cloudsme

Comment:
The deep sepia obsures the details that are available in this image. By lightening the tone, the detail will emerge and the veiwer doesn't need to work to capture the feel, mood, emotion that should be come easily. (By the way, IMO) The border should either be there or not be there, but not half way in between. This image could have done without it.

Greenhouses
by joebok

Comment:
I could copy and past this to several other images in this challenge: The deep sepia obsures the details that are available in this image. By lightening the tone, the detail will emerge and the veiwer doesn't need to work to capture the feel, mood, emotion that should be come easily. (By the way, IMO)

Forgotten
by Chiqui

Comment:
The border adds nothing to the scene, the sky is beautiful but at the expense of the subject (jmo) I personally like the overall ambience, with a little adjustment_as mentioned

Decay in Springtime
by mannjudit

Comment:
By cropping the top of this image off and making it a square presentation the subject matter becomes more revelant. The branches with the white flowers dominate the scene and add confusion. Wth a hint of them, the viewer sees the contrast of rot and decay amongst early spring foliage

House of Ghosts
by AntonS

Comment:
The deep sepia tones obsure the detail and detract from the overall image. That's just my opinion and here is the only place it counts. It makes me work to determine the subject and feel of the image and that gives a veiwer an inclination to make a snap judgement and go onto the next image without rating it on its other merits, which I have resisted. It is a beautiful sky, but too much of it. By cropping down to just above the house, so the image is then verticle, the veiwer is then drawn into the subject and it becomes the focus of attention. Tthen_even the deep sepia is not such a deterence.