Pick On Someone Your Own Size!
by whitetiger

Comment:
Really neat series! It matched up pretty well with the outer panels at an angle, but not with the building (I think these angled cells add more interest, even if they don't match up exactly, but a perfect shot would have matched it all using a tripod with a flex head. 9 Rob the Swash (and anthropologist!)

Rolling waves
by agwright

Comment:
Very nice scene! Was this three shots or one separated? (It does NOT matter, just curious, I think it's one shot) Nice dramatic cloudy sky (is this somewhere on the Puget Sound? or otherwise near me?) The one crashing wave is nice, but the rest of the water seems a bit too calm (now, isn't that asking for the sun, moon and the stars....no score impact). The rocks on the lower left seem a bit dark (duh, it's a cloudy day....). 9 Rob the Swash

Newtonian
by pinback

Comment:
Very, very cool idea!! The execution is nearly perfect, too. Was this one image divided or three separate shots? (I think it's three, but it's hard to say for certain) The strings of the "still" balls seem to have a bit of motion. Here's a complete nit for you...the shadows of the outside still balls aren't quite parallel with the other four (really, no score impact, just pointing out a tiny, insignificant flaw) 9 Rob the Swash

Breaking Free
by FranziskaLang

Comment:
Very nice series! Good detail and nice imagination to come up with this! The lower cell is just fine, emulates flight well. It would have been truly impossible to catch them in real flight, but I would have liked it a touch better (how many years to do this???). 9 Rob the Swash

After the Rain
by Kaz

Comment:
Very nice shots, great amounts of detail. (The flowers look almost too wet.) I really like the lighting on the 2nd and 3rd cells, the first is pretty good, but a tad glaring at the top. Focus seems pretty sharp, too bad the narsissus' outer petals reach out of focus, but camera reality (I hope the viewers don't fixate on that too much). Without the glare spot, this is a 10. High 9 - Rob the Swash

Dream Cars
by orussell

Comment:
Neat idea! Very clear shots. Lighting is harsh and glaring. The angled views of the cars is very nice. This is a bit of a nit (and probably asking for too much), but two Porsches and a Toyota? I would suggest more variety or less (no points involved at all). 7 Rob the Swash

A Day on The East Lancashire Railway
by Paulk

Comment:
Nice series! I really like the two cells on the left, good feeling for trains coming and going. The upper right frame is very good with extremely difficult lighting, but it doesn't show me what they are doing (keeping the audience guessing might be a good thing, but I doubt it). The lower right frame is well focused, but the overcast takes away quite a bit of the spendor (maybe shotting this more level would have looked better). 7 Rob the Swash

retired, but still attracting people
by kenbo

Comment:
Good collection of train parts. I like the top frame best. The middle frame seems a tad over exposed, the red seems so bright as to be unnatural (but I'm going to assume the painter found a VERY bright paint). Lower frame has some parts that seem over exposed, too (same silver colored parts). This is a difficult challenge due to the small frames needed. You got close enough for nice details, maybe too close to get a feel for the machinery. Very hard to call (too close vs not enough detail), I honestly think you did pretty well. 7 Rob the Swash

Life of Steel
by OneSweetSin

Comment:
All well taken images. The center one is a bit hard to tell what it is, but the others seem pretty recognizable. Seems more like that latter half "Life of Steel", how about Rust Starts Here? It's a nice collection of shots, but I'm having a hard time getting into it. 7 Rob the Swash

Rite of Passage
by DougPaz

Comment:
Good idea for a series. The color and choice of backgrounds is very nice. Lighting is great for the first cell, but a bit too glaring for the center cell, in between for the last cell. Though the first and last cells are close to the same arrangement, the extra green in the last cell is a bit distracting. 7 Rob the Swash