Fairy Godmother Cake
by Samara

Comment:
This looks like something my Mom would make! (Are you my MOM?). It's not just the cake, but the cup and saucer, lace, and mostly the Fairy Godmother! I give it a 10!

Rigatoni Lovers
by A Weaver

Comment:
The colors work great in this dish, and the composition is very nice. I'd like to eat some of this right now! The only things I can think to improve would be to show the ends of both pieces of silverware, and to get the wine in the cup to sit level.Thos are just small nit picking, as everything esle is perfect! Very nice...
JD Anderson

Old Family Recipe
by dsidwell

Comment:
I especially like the wooden rolling pin and the old family picture. They really make the photo for me. The bread looks awesome, too! Well done.
JD Anderson

Cappuccino Crème Brûlée
by Gordon

Comment:
So far, this is my favorite shot in the challenge. I love the composition, with just 1/4 of the cup showing, with handle. I've seen shots with coffee beans surrounding the cup, but never in it too! Great job! I give it a 9 (10 if it had just a little more DOF for the handle). JD Anderson

Mystery Revealed
by Tarbini

Comment:
10 from me! The 'key' to so many things in life! Great job.
JD Anderson

Colour of Fall
by tommy_t

Comment:
This gets a 10 from me! The simple elegance of this shot is wonderful. The negative space really caught my attention, then the pattern of the veins in the leaf compliment the shape of the leaf nicely. Well done!
JD Anderson

Deer's Revenge!
by buzzrock

Comment:
I had a feeling there would be one like this, and you pulled it off perfectly! Reminds me of the Farside! Too funny! 10
JD Anderson

Future Pilot
by Sonifo

Comment:
Great image, Sonja! Congrats on another ribbon. You are going to have such great photos for your children (and yourself) once they are grown!
Take care,
JD

Lower Scores
by jimmythefish

Comment:
Is this Jimmythefish??? I too bought a 10D and 70-200 4.0L and my scores are lower than normal! What's up with that? I'm giving you a 10...
JD Anderson

Half Empty or Not full
by Turbotech

Comment:
I gave this a 10 in that challenge, but just noticed I did not comment on it at the time. My bad... I usually comment on all my 9 and 10 scores. Great shot... very creative. I thought it was a mirror reflection until I read your notes. Very nice lighting... must have been abducted...
JD