soft landing
by shutterfly

Comment:
"Critique Club"

This one is very hard to know what to say about it. It has its good as well as bad points. Your focus is really good and the detail is fantastic as you can see the textures.

Problems with the photo are simple, its over exposed, more so on the top center, that bright spot is just very distracting there.

As for meeting the challenge I understand where you were coming from with this photo but at the same time it is very weak and doesn't really represent flight in this photo. Remember not everyone will think outside of the actually discription of the challenge.

Nice effort would love to see this redone with some spot editing done to it to correct the overexposure area.

Bats and Vampires!
by jetstar

Comment:
Wow this really works as a nightmare. Good capture, seems a little soft but could be movement of the bat too. Worth a 7 cause it is a nightmare

Do As I Say, Not As I Do
by WildflowerJoy

Comment:
Good finish Mary! Well done.

The Wave
by Shannon

Comment:
*Critique Club*

Very interesting macro. It has a lot of potential. The compositing is good the problem is the lighting was just to poor and ruined a beautiful photo. I'd love to see this done over with better lighting.

It meets the challenge, just watch out for shadows. Good attempt.

Quickly Burning
by solarys

Comment:
*Critique Club*

Nice image of the match burning. Lighting is very good for this subject, focus is excellent, and your composition is good.

As for meeting the challenge I find it slightly weak on that. I understand its meaning about how fast life goes by but I am sure there were voters that didn't think about it.

Very nice photo over all well done.

Broken Home
by Nazgul

Comment:
Title works very well for this photo. Very good photojournalism too.

Desolated
by Nazgul

Comment:
I love this photo it really has a feeling to it I have felt before.

tempiale del fungo
by JC_Homola

Comment:
The color and lines make this photo so interesting.

at rest
by GinaRothfels

Comment:
I really like the lighting on this. Should have given her a packet of sugar to rest her head on to ensure sweet dreams. ;o) Well worth a 10

A moment of peace in the city
by Alexys

Comment:
I like it a lot with one little exception there is a stong glare coming off the car. I would give it a 10 if not for that glare but still worth an 8.