smells like winter
by ursula

Comment:
Very nice photo. Reflection in water is great. Nice composition and good color tone.

burnt
by GinaRothfels

Comment:
Good depiction of the challenge. I can smell the sulphur already. Nice composition and good tones. I would have liked the matches in the box to be lit a little more evenly though. 9

Who was playing with matches!?
by zummer

Comment:
Great photo of the matches burning. I can smell the sulphur already. Excellent job. Good composition, good tones and excellent depiction of your topic for the challenge. 10

Aromatic
by amsmyth

Comment:
Very good photo. Nice texture, good composition and meets the challenge well. My only critique is the cut piece of garlic is a little out of focus and the reflection of the light source takes away from that part of the photo. 8

Aroma is inspired by nature
by ramevi

Comment:
I think this is a very good photo. I assume the soft look was intentional so I won't say "it could be sharper." However, I think I would like it a little better if you could have captured it without the shadows as the white between the flower and the stamen is a little blown out. All in all I think this is a very good photo though.

Mmmm....Popcorn
by CraigD

Comment:
Great picture and I can smell the popcorn already. In my case I can smell the burnt popcorn. I like this photo a lot. Good composition and good thought as to how to portray your thoughts. I was just wondering if there was some way you could have triggered the microwave to think the door was closed and turn the light off. It is a little disturbing to what otherwise is a great photo. 9

Ahhhhhhh.... nothing like the smell of coffee in the morning.
by kosmikkreeper

Comment:
I like this photo a lot and it certainly makes me smell the coffee. However, I am wondering how this would have looked in straight b&w. The only thing that is disturbing are the reflections from your light source. 9

A Pure Scent
by librodo

Comment:
Love your photo and in this case the border helps the picture. Wonderful photo. 10

Morning Coffee
by Artifacts

Comment:
Very good depiction of your smell/odor. It certainly reminds me of morning. I am giving it a 9 because IMHO I think the stream of coffee could use some work as far as lighting is concerned. It is distracting to see the diamonds of white from the lighting source you have used. All in all a great photo though. 9

The Cuban aroma
by Jason

Comment:
This is a great picture and I would consider it a 10 if there had been a little more smoke trail from the cigar. It is there but not significantly to make an impact. All in all a wonderful photo though. 9